Water Damage Suit Finds ADT Caught Without Contract

A homeowner’s insurance carrier recently sued ADT for $700,000 for water damage to their home caused by freezing pipes. According to the complaint, ADT agreed to install and monitor low temperature in the home. It’s alleged that ADT failed to notify anyone of the low temperature.

As I read this the tail of “Three Blind Mice” kept coming to mind. The judge eventually got around to an acceptable decision, though this case is likely to come back to haunt the alarm industry for a long time to come. Thanks ADT; and yes, it’s your fault. Why? Three reasons, at least.

First, ADT either didn’t have a written contract (unusual for ADT) or lost it. ADT claimed it couldn’t find the contract and tried an end run, unconvincingly apparently. But the failings of the plaintiff subrogation counsel saved ADT, somewhat, because the complaint did not separate the allegations supporting the complaint’s three causes of action: breach of contract, negligence and gross negligence.

Second, ADT moved the case form an upstate New York State court to a New York upstate federal court. Why the ADT attorneys thought they would do better in federal court is beyond me.

For one thing, appeals in federal court are limited while the case is making its way to final judgment. Also, a federal judge will look to what the state’s highest court has ruled on the issues, and so you have a federal judge trying to interpret what the state court has previously ruled.

In this case, the federal judge decided to discuss a state court ruling dealing with a large monetary NYC fire loss where New York’s highest court ruled there are times that even a breach of contract can support an independent tort claim (for negligence).

So far, that NYC case hasn’t had much traction adverse to the alarm industry, but that is very likely to change as a result of this new federal court decision. On behalf of subrogation lawyers and their insurance carrier clients as well as alarm customers, thanks ADT! If this was a state court decision there would be chance of appeal, but not in this federal case.

Third, and finally, ADT’s lawyers decided to make a motion attacking the pleadings, something I wrote about in the March 23 article, “Medical Alert Lawsuit Survives Motion to Dismiss in Death Case in GA.”

As I mentioned there, a pre-answer motion to dismiss based on failure to properly plead a cause of action rarely works. What it does do is generate lots of money for the lawyers and often leads to bad decisions (bad in the sense of being prejudicial to the litigants and also making bad law, which it might in this ADT case).

If ADT didn’t have a contract it could find, it probably should have considered a different defense strategy that didn’t include a pre-answer motion to dismiss.

This case certainly drives home the necessity of using, getting signed and retaining proper alarm contracts with your customers. Do not work without a proper contract! Of course, my opinions expressed here are my own, for what they are worth. We all wish ADT well in the case (Great Northern Insurance Company A/S/O Shira White v. ADT), which you can keep up with at the website noted above.

The post Water Damage Suit Finds ADT Caught Without Contract appeared first on Security Sales & Integration.



from News Archives - Security Sales & Integration https://www.securitysales.com/columns/water-damage-suit-finds-adt-caught-without-contract/
via IFTTT

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Total Tech Summit Puts Call Out for Top Integrators to Apply Now

Image
FRAMINGHAM, Mass. — Total Tech Summit announces that applications are now being accepted to attend this year’s event. Comprised of the  SSI Summit, CE Pro Summit and Commercial Integrator Summit, this year’s event will take place in Las Vegas at the MGM Grand Hotel and Casino, Nov. 13-15. At this all-expense-paid, exclusive event, VIP guests will have the chance to sit in on industry-defining sessions, key boardroom presentations, and be able to meet one-on-one with potential vendors. Total Tech Summit brings together the best in class to share ideas, learn from others, and most importantly, accelerating the next stage of their businesses. It is the only event of its kind that bridges channels and connections by bringing together professional security, commercial AV and residential AV integrators. Another perk of the Total Tech Summit is the VIP Peer-to-Peer groups. These group conversations take place throughout the months leading up to the event and are guided by the editors of t
Read more

Evolv Technology, Pittsburgh Pirates Team Up for Fan-Friendly Ballpark Security

Image
WALTHAM, Mass.—Evolv Technology has announced its partnership with Major League Baseball’s Pittsburgh Pirates, adding to the growing list of Pittsburgh, Pa. venues that have teamed up with Evolv to help keep people safe, including the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust and Acrisure Stadium, home of the Pittsburgh Steelers. When the Pirates opened the gates at PNC Park for the 2023 MLB season in early April, all attending fans passed through Evolv’s state-of-the-art Evolv Express screening solution, which uses sensor technology with artificial intelligence (AI) to provide safer, more accurate threat detection at unprecedented volume and speed, the company states. Fans can now walk through without always having to stop or open bags, reducing long lines and allowing guests to make their way directly into the ballpark. “What continues to make PNC Park so special, aside from the physical design, is the total fan experience. That begins from the moment they walk up to our gates,” said Travis Willi
Read more

Minnesota AG Calls for Cancellation of Home Security Contracts for Alleged Fraud

STEARNS COUNTY, Minn. — Bring Me the News reports that Minnesota’s Attorney General, Keith Ellison, says he’s gotten consumers in Stearns County out of home security contracts after they were misled by a door-to-door salesman. According to the report, Ellison’s office announced that home security companies Skyline Security Management and Safe Home Security have agreed to their cancel contracts with customers in and around Stearns County who purchased their systems from door-to-door salesman Gary Harvey. “Door-to-door salesmen and their employers are in the business of trust-building,” Ellison said in a statement. “They know they need to have your trust to sell you their products, particularly expensive products like security systems that are supposed to keep your home safe. When that trust is betrayed, it’s emotionally and financially painful. I appreciate Skyline and Safe Home taking the right step in canceling these contracts while my office does what we can under the law to hold M
Read more